manufacturing

The Inventor Q&A – Edition 2

Common invention-related questions answered by invention marketing/licensing expert Russell Williams of Invention Home.
Latest posts by Russell Williams (see all)

Russell Williams founded Invention Home over 6 years ago to assist inventors with the marketing and licensing of their ideas. He’s been asked nearly every invention-related question in the book, and shares his wisdom with you in this series, "The Inventor Q&A." 

Question:

What is the difference between having an invention and just having an idea?

Answer:

On the surface, this sounds like a very basic and common sense question, but in reality inventors often confuse having an “idea” for an “invention.” The definition of an invention is “a device, contrivance or process originated after study and experiment.” An idea is defined as “a formulated thought or opinion.”

Based on these definitions, inventors should consider the amount of “study or experiment” they have really done to justify terming an “idea” as an “invention.” Think of it this way, do you have a tangible solution for something or have you just identified a problem that needs a solution?

The real challenge with inventing is not just identifying a need, but also figuring out a solution and even more so, how that solution works. For example, if you wake up with an idea for an engine that runs on water, you’d better figure out how it works before you start classifying your idea as an invention.

Question:

Can you provide a simple explanation of what “patentability” means?

Answer:

When the patent office reviews patent applications to determine whether they will grant a patent, they review to see if the stated invention meets a set of predetermined requirements, thereby qualifying it as “patentable.” The requirements state that an invention must be new (or novel), useful, and non-obvious (meaning, not obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the art).

New and useful improvements to existing products can also be patented. One of the mostly commonly reviewed requirements is the novelty (newness) test, which considers whether other patents already exist on your invention. This process involves reviewing and understanding existing patents as well as non-patented, similar products (together called “prior art”) to determine the unique qualities (“novelty”) of your invention.

The patent examiner will perform a prior art search during the patent review process. He/she could ultimately cite older, existing patents as a basis for denying your patent application, which would then require your attorney to respond to the patent examiner with an explanation of how your invention is different. Keep in mind that even if you conduct a patent search and receive a preliminary “patentability opinion” prior to moving forward with a patent application, there are no guarantees that your patent application will “pass” the patent criteria followed by the Patent Office.

It is important to understand that this process is not an exact science. A patent attorney will do his or her best to find applicable prior art and to make a determination, but with the millions of patents that exist today, you will never receive a 100% guarantee.

For help in licensing
an invention, click here for a free information kit.

Read other editions of
The Inventor Q&A:

Total
0
Shares
Previous Article

The OPRAH...effect!

Next Article
repeat business

How to Avoid Triggering an IRS Audit

Related Posts
home-based businesses
Read More

The Value of Home-Based Businesses to Economic Recovery

The challenge of America’s economic recovery, in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, is to spread it to every community – and especially those that have been historically excluded. The key to meeting that challenge is to appreciate the civic and economic value of an overlooked resource: home-based businesses. There are about 16 million home-based...
Read More

WJR Business Beat: Job Switchers Rewarded with Higher Pay (Episode 406)

On today's Business Beat, Jeff Sloan talks about how it's going to be more difficult and costly for small businesses to hire the best talent because job switchers during the pandemic have seen significant salary hikes. Tune in to today's Business Beat for more:   Tune in to News/Talk 760 AM WJR weekday mornings at...
startup team
Read More

5 Strategies for Building a Great Startup Team

The way you treat your employees, their time, skills and abilities in the early phases of your union as a team influences the rest of your company's course of action. Mark Zuckerberg once said, "The most important thing for you as an entrepreneur trying to build something is, you need to build a really good...
pitch videos
Read More

How Pitch Videos Can Help Your Startup Get Funding

When you’re about to launch a startup, gaining the interest and support of startup investors is an important element in becoming a successful brand. These days, videos are a great way of communicating information and landing you anything from seed funding to crowdfunding. After all, a great pitch video can grab your investors’ and consumers’...